EU Court: Luxembourg to decide the future of unlicensed online betting
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has in recent days hosted a pivotal hearing that could redefine the legal framework of the online sports betting sector. In Luxembourg, judges are debating whether players may be entitled to reimbursement for stakes lost with bookmakers that operated without a German licence – an issue with potentially far-reaching consequences, not only in Germany but across the entire European Union.
The dispute between a player and Tipico
The case sparking this debate involves a player who filed a lawsuit against bookmaker Tipico. Initially examined by Germany’s Federal Court of Justice (BGH) in Karlsruhe, the proceedings were suspended to allow Europe’s top court to weigh in. The key legal question is whether the EU’s principle of freedom to provide services can override the national licensing requirement, which Tipico had not fulfilled until 2020, despite having already applied for authorisation.
The dispute focuses on the bookmaker’s activities before the licence was formally granted. Players argue that contracts signed during that period should be considered void and the stakes refunded. In preliminary remarks, the BGH hinted at sympathy for this view, raising expectations among claimants who have taken legal action.
National licences and EU law
At the heart of the matter lies the compatibility of Germany’s licensing procedures with European principles of transparency and fair competition. Should those procedures be found inconsistent with EU law, the absence of a national licence may not carry full legal weight.
The CJEU has addressed a similar issue in the past in a criminal context, ruling that the lack of a German licence could not be held against operators already authorised in another EU member state, provided the German system was opaque. The current debate is whether that reasoning should also extend to civil cases, potentially opening the door to a wave of reimbursement claims.
Positions on the line
On the operators’ side, Tipico has expressed confidence in the outcome. A company spokesperson reaffirmed their expectation of a decision consistent with prior CJEU rulings, which have tended to prioritise the free provision of services within the single market.
Conversely, players and their supporters maintain a starkly different position. Hannes Beuck, co-founder of Gamesright – a litigation funder backing player claims – stressed that unlawful conduct by operators cannot be left without consequences. In his view, only the annulment of wagers placed without a licence will ensure a fairer betting market, protecting consumers and restoring trust in the sector.
The implications for the European market
The CJEU’s ruling, expected in the coming months, will not merely settle the fate of Tipico or of the players involved in pending lawsuits. Its impact could reverberate throughout the European online sports betting industry. In Germany alone, thousands of cases are currently on hold pending clarification, but the precedent set in Luxembourg will also be closely scrutinised in other member states.
If the court declares contracts with unlicensed operators void where national licensing systems breach EU law, regulators may be compelled to overhaul their frameworks. On the other hand, a ruling favouring operators would reinforce the principle of service freedom as a prevailing value over national restrictions.
A decision the sector awaits
The legal debate unfolding in Luxembourg is therefore far more than a dispute between a player and a bookmaker. At stake is the very definition of Europe’s regulatory perimeter for online betting, at a time when member states are grappling with how to balance consumer protection with a rapidly expanding, digital and cross-border market.
The CJEU’s decision could prove a watershed moment, establishing new rules of the game for both operators and customers, while shaping the regulatory trajectory of the industry in years to come. Until the judgment is delivered, the market remains in suspense, aware that Luxembourg holds the power to redefine the future of online sports betting in Europe.
This article was first published in Italian on 29 September 2025.
All roads lead to Rome, 03–06 November 2025. SiGMA Central Europe takes centre stage at the Fiera Roma, uniting 30,000 delegates, 1,200 exhibitors, and 700+ speakers. This is where legacies are built, and the future takes shape. Connect with the innovators’ driving change.
